Clean Water, Dirty Ads: When Rivalry Becomes Disparagement
By Shine Gupta
11/18/20265 min read


They say, "Everything's fair in love and war." I guess this one was war.
Urban Company and Kent RO are the two main market-share holders, i.e., direct competitors in the home water purifier market. But why is that relevant? Because not every competitive rivalry results in public defamation and a courtroom battle.
Let’s unpack this –
How the Case Unfolded
First Phase
In late 2023, the trigger began. Urban Company launched its Native water purifier series with a hefty ‘no service needed for two years’ promise. A big claim to make for a mechanical device, isn’t it? Absolutely. That claim was the ignition mark for the advertisement battle that flared between Urban Company and Kent RO.
In 2024 came Kent’s patent suit. It went to court, filing a patent infringement lawsuit in the Delhi High Court, claiming that Urban Company’s Native RO design copied its patented technology without authorisation. Urban Company retaliated by denying the claim and further challenged its validity.
As part of its throwdown, Urban Company sued Kent, alleging that Kent wrote to Amazon and Flipkart asking them to delist Urban Company’s water purifiers, even though there was no court order to justify it. Kent subsequently questioned the authenticity of the communications and sought time to take instructions. Meanwhile, Kent was restricted from entering into conversation with e-commerce platforms until the next hearing. This is the matter Urban Company later describes as its tortious interference suit.
Second Phase
Cut to 2026, on 11 August, Urban Company brought to the Delhi HC a defamation and disparagement suit against Kent Ro, further fueling their longstanding rivalry. The suit was centred around the advertisements by Kent Ro targeting the two-year filter life and two-year service life features offered on Native M0, M1, M2, M1 Pro and M2 Pro purifiers by Urban Company. The plaintiff company alleged that the defendant’s campaign, which included influencer-promoted content, called the features a “marketing gimmick” and portrayed Native purifiers in the public eye as “unsafe” and “risky”.
The hearing for the case was held the following day on 12 August 2026. The case was heard by Justice A. J Bhambhani, and the verdict moved Kent to remove the challenged advertisements and social media content. Kent further promised that it would refrain from publishing other advertisements and promotional content making similar or the same claims about water purifiers offering a two-year filter life or a two-year no-service feature in a manner that disparages Urban Company. The court directed the removal of defamatory content within 15 days from August 12. The order was passed on the same day and published on the court website on August 22. Following this, Urban Company disclosed the suit in a regulatory filing on Sunday, August 23.


The Aftermath
Now, the question might arise: why is this case relevant? Because this case operates on a very thin line of how much you can push against your competitors before it becomes disparagement. It draws a line between what you can say about your rivals and what you can't, and how this line gets blurrier as advertisements become more social media-centric.
Attack Ads: The Real Glimpse Behind Negative Advertisement
The above case is a prime example of attack ads and how they can sometimes cross a boundary and lead to legal consequences.
But what are attack ads?
Attack ads are advertisements that criticize a political opponent or rival brand rather than focusing on the sponsor’s own policies or positive attributes.
More often than not, these public defamation stunts end up exposing the flaws in all products, leading to consumers comparing brands based on shortcomings.
“When you’re highlighting your competitor’s weaknesses, you can also bring to the mind of the consumer the similarities between yours and theirs,” Yildirim said. “Once companies start attacking each other, it ends up destroying the whole product category and the whole industry seems to suffer.”
This can give rise to a situation of a “prisoner’s dilemma”, wherein both companies would favour positive advertising if they cooperated instead of lashing out at each other. When attack ads work from both sides, it can easily turn ugly, destroying consumer trust and, sometimes, both brands defeating the initial purpose overall.
Why do Brands Run Attack Ads?
If there are a million ways negative advertising can go wrong, doing more harm than good, why do companies seem to gravitate towards them time and time again? The answer is very simple. Because they work.
No doubt these operate in a gray area, inviting increased consumer trust and legal backlash equally. But the reasons for adopting them are quite appealing-
Strengthening Brand Identity and Consumer Tribes-
Positioning your brand against a competitor helps in establishing a distinctive personality and fostering consumer loyalty. Brands can present themselves as a “sleek rebel” or a “pragmatic innovator,” as seen in the Apple-Samsung rivalry.


Appealing to Gen Z values-
The younger generation tends to gravitate towards bold and cheeky brands that are fearless in establishing their brand in the market and capturing the market share effortlessly. This brand loyalty from younger audiences is an appealing enough incentive to make brands go the extra mile.


How Rude Can an Ad Be? Where Does the Court Draw the Line?
From this discussion, another question arises: if attack ads are such a common practice, how do courts tell fair comparison from disparagement? The answer lies in some simple frameworks that follow all legal suits-
Candor behind remarks -
As long as the claims are factually accurate and backed by objective data, they do not qualify as product disparagement. But, indulging in misleading or manipulative facts to create a false narrative can invite legal action.
The intent behind the remark-
Advertisements in general are positioned to bring the company’s product in a brighter light. The same principle is extended here: as long as the intent behind the comparison is to show that the competitor’s product is better, rather than to rock or aggressively slander the competitor’s goods, they operate in a safe zone.
Consumer perception -
A consumer’s conclusion from the ad should be of a routine comparison, weighing pros and cons rather than walking away with a lasting impression that the rival’s product is dangerous or worthless.
